PDA

View Full Version : When push comes to shove...



Colonel Carter
08-07-2006, 02:01 AM
If tempers were lost and friends turned on each other in anger, which two would you most want to see get into a fight? Shoving, maybe throwing punches, etc... You can vote for more than one.

cb49747
08-08-2006, 01:34 PM
I chose McKay and Beckett, only because I think that would be the only fight worth watching. The rest would be way to one sided.

Nikki&Beckett
08-08-2006, 02:42 PM
I'd say Beckett and McKay, cause honestly Beckett would probably kick McKay's *** which would be funny to me.

Colonel Carter
08-08-2006, 08:31 PM
So far every fight voted for involves poor ol' Beckett. :p

A fight between McKay and Beckett would probably be very humorous to watch, really because anything involving McKay tends to be humorous. McKay is pretty much the show's comedy relief. I'm having a hard time imagining those two losing their tempers with each other to the point of a physical altercation though. I see the most between them being arguments like in the last episode which were funny for the audience to watch.

I voted for Sheppard and Beckett. Yeah Sheppard would have an advantage because he is trained military and Beckett is a civilian doctor. But I think if those two lost their tempers with each other that the moment would be more tense and dramatic and not at all have humor like if it were between McKay and Beckett. And I'm thinking such a thing could be good for character development whereas any fight involving McKay would just be to add a comedy element into the episode. And because Beckett isn't military, he couldn't get court marshalled for striking an officer.

I could see this a lot more easily after the episode where Michael had rallied the Wraith on that planet. Beckett was very upset with Sheppard's attitude and actions in that episode and I could see that tension building in the future. I think Beckett could get a good punch in if he swings first when Shep isn't expecting it. Though that would seem a little out of character for him. I could see it more where they're in an argument which escelates and they get in each others' faces.

Anissa T
08-18-2006, 08:04 PM
I put Shep and McKay, because I would secretly hope McKay would win. It would put Shep in his place and give McKay some confindence and hopefully in the process tone down the arrogence.

Colonel Carter
08-20-2006, 01:36 PM
McKay beat Sheppard?! XD

Anissa T
08-20-2006, 01:54 PM
Hey, I could hope!

Colonel Carter
08-20-2006, 01:59 PM
And Martin (Marty) could beat Jack! :p

Angelica Constantine
09-02-2006, 01:04 PM
I voted for McKay and Beckett. Well, I really like McKay (he is a lot like me personally) and well I don't like Beckett. McKay I think if he really wanted to he could kick some serious butt. ;)